The lone flower. Since the news of their split, viewers of The Bachelorette have been curious as to the real reason Gabby and Erich decided to end their relationship.
It was in 2022, when Gabby Windey was the Bachelorette on The Bachelorette alongside Rachel Recchia, that she and Erich Schwer first met. (Gabby and Rachel competed for the heart of Clayton Echard on season 26 of The Bachelor but were ultimately eliminated in third place.)
On the season 19 finale of “The Bachelorette,” Gabby proposed to Erich and ultimately chose him as the winner. Upon first meeting you, it was as if a veil had been lifted and I could be myself without any inhibitions at all.
In all my years of life, I’ve never found anyone with whom I could feel such an instant and profound rapport. Erich told Gabby this in his proposal, “I felt like I really knew you for years.” I had no idea that I had already found my soul mate.
The moment you let your guard down was the moment I knew our relationship had reached an inconceivably high plateau. … When I’m talking to you, I feel like I’m the only one alive. And for the rest of my life, I intend to do whatever it takes to preserve that sensation.
Oh, Gabby Windey, how much I adore you. That’s incredible, what you’ve done here. Truly, I cannot think of a more incredible human being than you. Til the very end, it’s just us two. You have my undying devotion and I hope to spend eternity with you.
Will Erich Schwer Still Be Seeing Gabby Windey?
Gabby and Erich’s breakup occurred less than two months after the season 19 finale of The Bachelorette.
Erich appeared to show Gabby some love on November 7 via Instagram Stories as she continued to compete on the 31st season of Dancing With the Stars. She’s doing great, and he urged his readers to keep casting ballots. During the episode of DWTS airing on November 14, Gabby addressed the breakup.
After explaining that she had recently gone through a breakup, Gabby danced the waltz to Des’ree’s “I’m Kissing You,” and she explained why the song was meaningful to her in her introduction package. “We broke up because we just weren’t completely in sync with each other in terms of our goals in life and how we approached it. We just weren’t meant to be together.”
Erich commented on the breakup in an Instagram Stories post, saying that the two were “not each other’s people” in the end.
He called Gabby an “amazing person” on November 15, but admitted that it was difficult to pinpoint exactly why they were breaking up. I’m glad we crossed paths in such a singular setting and fashion. I can never take it back now.
Approximately How Long Ago Did Gabby Windey And Erich Schwer Break Up?
It was during one of Gabby’s DWTS performances that a Reddit user initially questioned whether the two were still an item. In late October, a fan posted on Reddit, “Why I think Gabby and Erich broke up.”
One of the reasons Erich won’t be at DWTS tonight, as well as last Tuesday, is stated in the post as “1.
For the past week, we have agreed to refrain from sharing any joint photos or narratives online. Third, since around 10/12, Gabby hasn’t posted or re-posted anything having to do with Erich. 4. At one point, Jenna Johnson was following Erich on Twitter but has since unfollowed him.
In addition to not wearing her ring to dances, Gabby hasn’t been wearing it at all. She hasn’t been showing it off with her pals or at the Halloween party this weekend. Sixth, mysterious or out-of-the-ordinary Instagram posts (please someone come get their milkshake, she’s having chicken soup with her parents).
After the DWTS Halloween episode, Gabby was the first to address the rumors. She told Fox News on October 31 that “life is just really busy for the both of us right now.” To paraphrase, “I get [Bachelor Nation’s] concern, but we’re just kind of going forward with each of our individual interests and supporting each other from afar.”
Gabby had told reporters a week earlier that Erich had been “really supportive” throughout her time on the show.
What Happened To Gabby And Erich After The Bachelorette Finale?
The couple passed the show’s initial test by leaving the show as a couple, but the real test came when Erich kept getting in trouble with the show’s viewers.
The controversy started when a yearbook photo of the New Jersey native dressed in Blackface made the rounds on the internet.
“I wholeheartedly apologize for the insensitive photo of me in Blackface from my high school yearbook that has been circulating,” Erich wrote via Instagram on September 8, captioning a photo of a black square.
What I took to be a symbol of my admiration for Jimi Hendrix at the time turned out to be nothing more than my own naivete. I was naïve to the hurtful implications of my actions to the Black community and those closest to me, and will forever regret my offensive and damaging behavior.”
In his final post, he admitted, “I am deeply ashamed by my actions and understand that my apology is only the first step in taking accountability.”
Erich’s ex-girlfriend Amanda Kaylor allegedly leaked their text messages less than a week later. She told Reality Steve, per his podcast, that she and Erich broke up because he wanted to continue dating her while auditioning for The Bachelorette.
“I know this isn’t ideal. I wanted to do this to see if there was something else I could do with my life. As for me, Amanda, you have my undying admiration. I didn’t think it would be a big deal but I understand how you feel,” Erich allegedly wrote in one of the texts shared by the Instagram page BachelorNation. Scoop.
How Serious Were Gabby Windey And Erich Schwer’s Engagement Rumors?
During the season finale, Erich popped the question to Gabby, and the two are now engaged. Fans saw Erich get nervous about popping the question, though.
During a candid conversation, he told Gabby, “I just, like, I want to date you.” In most cases, “things don’t go the way of getting engaged before that.”
When asked what she should do, the leading lady walked away sobbing. Give up on him because he’s not ready to pop the question.
Nonetheless, Erich changed his mind and proposed to Gabby with a beautiful ring from Neil Lane.
Windey’s participation in season 31 of Dancing with the Stars was first reported on September 8, 2022. The pair, which also included Val Chmerkovskiy, placed second. During the finale, it was revealed that she would be joining the cast on the Dancing with the Stars Live 2023 tour as a co-host.